Mighty Mouse doesn’t save the day + diagram of my budget KVM solution
I love my 7+ year old Microsoft Intellimouse 3.0.
The problem is that it’s wired, an inconvenience since it’s plugged in behind my desk.

As a sort of low budget KVM solution I have everything plugged into a USB hub. The USB hub’s “to computer” cable end sits on my desk and is usually plugged into my MacBookPro. From my older Ubuntu/WinXP PC on the floor a USB extender cable snakes up on to my desk. My monitor has two “ins”, DVI to the laptop and analog VGA to the PC.

When I want to run out to a code jam and bring my mouse it’s annoying to have to get under the desk and yank the mouse of the hub.
I wanted to go wireless, and since I my laptop has Bluetooth built in, it made sense to look for a Bluetooth mouse. I was kind of shocked that there aren’t more BT mice available. The
most recent Microsoft BT mouse has an ambidexterous shape (not ergonomic enough, plus no thumb back/forward buttons). I really hate the new scroll wheels with side to side action because the click down action is so damn stiff. Easy wheel clicking is essential for me. I use it to close browser tabs or open links in tabs. Finally, the Microsoft BT mice don’t have off switches which means when you travel with them and they get jostled they come out of sleep mode and run out of juice.
The Logitech BT mouse offerings weren’t any more compelling than Microsoft’s.
In slight desperation, I went to Fry’s and bought the BT Mighty Mouse from Apple. I really wanted to like this mouse, but it has some pretty severe flaws.
The good:
I really like the ball/nipple scroll thingy. The up/down/left/right action was smooth, quick, and didn’t tire my finger at all. The middle click action was decent too.
It runs on either one or two standard AA batteries. With two batteries the mouse felt too heavy, with one battery it was perfect.
There is a nice off switch that covers the laser lens under the mouse.

The Bluetooth pairing and software were perfect.
The bad:
The shape is not ergonomic. I tired quickly using this mouse. My elbow is still a little out of sorts from using it for just two days.
There are no back or forward buttons. Instead there are two panels on the sides of the mouse that you have to squeeze VERY hard to activate Expose. I thought I was squeezing it wrong because it was so uncomfortably difficult. The squeeze is programmable to functions besides Expose, but so what when you’ve pulled a muscle just to activate the click?
Right clicking sucks. You have to pull your left finger up to right click reliably. Tiring.
The worst thing is the pointer tracking. I’m guessing that Bluetooth can’t support the sample rate I need for precise mousing. This is a common complaint from gamers regarding wireless mice. The BT Mighty Mouse just had really jumpy, inaccurate tracking. I tried it on different surfaces and nothing alleviated the problem.
Once again Apple has proved to be the best computer designer in the world that can’t produce a good mouse.
I ended up buying an extra Intellimouse 3.0 to keep in my laptop bag.
This entry was posted in
Design,
Reviews. Bookmark the
permalink. Follow any comments here with the
RSS feed for this post.
Great review!
“Precise mousing” is my new favorite phrase of the day
I was in the same Mac Mouse predicament several months ago, and found a solution I don’t regret in the least: the Logitech VX Revolution. I didn’t want a mouse dongle, but seriously, the way they did it is brilliant. The dongle stores inside the mouse when transporting, and removing the dongle from the mouse activates the “connect” mode so you don’t have to fool with connecting the mouse. It runs about 30-40 days on a single AA battery (at about 12 hours/day). It has a configurable flywheel for the scroll wheel, and a useless “zoom” feature that I reconfigured to activate Dashboard and Expose. Plus, side-side scrolling, back/forward buttons, etc. Seriously, it’s the best mouse I’ve had for my Mac. The only thing lacking is the Logitech software which seems rather bungled for mac, but it seems to accomplish the job well enough to not make me angry. Not to mention, I also take the mouse to work every day for my PC, and it works great there too. Best $50 on a mouse I’ve ever spent.
Thanks for the info David. How do you like the VX’s sample rate and accuracy?
Oh, it’s awesome. For gaming, I preferred my Logitech G7, but this is a laser mouse with probably 800-1000 DPI… It’s great enough for normal computer work (and much better than the opticals), but I wouldn’t completely trust it on heavy FPS gaming. I use it on some RPG and RTS games and it works just fine. I only wish it were bluetooth, but it is nice being able to use it on my Mac at home and PC at work with little problem (the dongle storage simply is genius).